Alan Tangren: Finding the best cherries |

Alan Tangren: Finding the best cherries


Dear Alan: I love cherries and would like to learn how to choose the best ones at the market. What varieties should I look for?

Alan: Sweet cherries are one of the true treasures of the springtime market. A good crop depends on the perfect combination of a cold winter, no frost during and after the bloom period, and warm, dry spring weather to bring them to perfect ripeness.

Look for sweet California cherries starting in mid to late May and enjoy their short season into June, although fruit from Oregon and Washington can extend the season into July.

Sweet cherries are one of the true treasures of the springtime market. A good crop depends on the perfect combination of a cold winter, no frost during and after the bloom period, and warm, dry spring weather to bring them to perfect ripeness.
Getty Images

It is harder to find true sour cherries in our area, but I have found them at Goldbud in Placerville. Most production is in cold northern states like Michigan and New York, and much of the crop is processed into canned cherries, jam and pie filling. Sour cherries have a later season, at its peak in late June.

The only preparation that crisp, sweet cherries really need is a quick rinse in cold water. Then eat them at will.

But cooked cherries, sweet and sour, have their own special place at the table. When cherry season is in full swing, I like to use them in pies, cobblers, tarts and the French favorite, clafoutis.

I usually pit cherries that will be served cooked. There are various cherry pitters at Tess’ that will do the job. Pit cherries just before using. It’s advisable to check each cherry after pitting, just to make sure the pit came out. Sometimes I count the cherries and the pits separately after pitting. If the numbers don’t match I check again!

Bing has long been recognized as the best quality dark sweet cherry. They are large, round and plump, with a crisp texture and rich, sweet flavor. Bings ripen toward the middle of cherry season, but some good earlier varieties are Black Tartarian, Tulare and Burlat. When the Bings are done, look for Lambert, Van and Black Republican.

There are two white cherry varieties that ripen in mid-season and are worth looking for. Royal Anne is an old French variety with ivory-yellow skin and blushing red cheeks. It has a perfect balance of sweet and tart character.

Cherry growers are replacing Royal Anne with another white cherry, Rainier, firmer and less likely to bruise. It is fine for eating fresh, but doesn’t have enough tartness to make it interesting when cooked.

Most cherries found in grocery stores are not labeled by variety, but the produce manager should be able to tell you what’s on display. Your best bet to learn about the different named varieties is at the farmer’s market, where you can ask farmers about specific characteristics of varieties they grow, and find your favorites.

When at the market, choose cherries that are bright and plump. Avoid any that are bruised, soft, or show signs of mold. Stems should be green and pliable. Refrigerate as soon as possible, packed loosely in a plastic bag.

At Chez Panisse we discovered a way to improve the qualities of the first cherries of the season if we couldn’t wait for ones with perfect flavor and ripeness. For two pounds of cherries, stem and wash them, and pit them or not. Place a pan that will hold them in a single layer over high heat, add the cherries and sprinkle on ¼ cup sugar. Lower heat to medium and cook for five minutes, tossing the cherries several times, until the sugar is dissolved and juices start to come out.

Stir in a teaspoon of kirsch and a tablespoon of balsamic vinegar. Remove from heat and let stand at room temperature for an hour or two for the flavors to develop. These are great served with a slice of pound cake, or over vanilla ice cream.

Pickled Cherries

To extend the too-short cherry season, you can pickle them and enjoy them months later. These are especially good alongside fatty meats like duck and pork.

2 pounds cherries

1-1/2 cups sugar

4-1/4 cups white wine vinegar

4 whole cloves

6 black peppercorns

Rinse, dry and pick over the cherries, and discard any blemished ones. Trim the stems to ½ inch.

Prepare 8 1-pint canning jars and self-sealing lids in boiling water, following manufacturer’s instructions.

Stir together the sugar, vinegar, cloves and peppercorns in a nonreactive saucepan, bring to a boil and simmer 3 minutes.

Pack the cherries into the canning jars and ladle the hot syrup over the cherries. Cover and seal the jars, following manufacturer’s instructions.

Let sit for two months in a cool, dark place before using. They should keep for several months after that in the refrigerator.

Chef Alan Tangren spent 22 years as a chef in the kitchens of Chez Panisse in Berkeley, eight of those years spent as the Chez Panisse forager. He teaches cooking classes and directs monthly Chef’s Tables at Tess’ Kitchen Store, 115 Mill Street in Grass Valley. Learn more at Contact him at

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

Readers around Grass Valley and Nevada County make The Union’s work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Your donation will help us continue to cover COVID-19 and our other vital local news.


Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.

User Legend: iconModerator iconTrusted User